R Street Institute

This page was last edited on at

R Street Institute is a US think tank based in Washington D.C. It describes itself as a “nonpartisan, public policy research organization” with a “mission is to engage in policy research and outreach to promote free markets and limited, effective government.”12

Background

R Street Institute was set up as a not-for-profit organisation in 2012 by former employees from the Heartland Institute and American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC),  and is a member of the State Policy Network.3 (See Think Tanks for more on ALEC and SPN).

Formerly named ‘D.C. Progress’ it was first registered as a nonprofit with the US tax authorities in 2009.4

Relationship with the Tobacco Industry

R Street Institute states that it is “funded by voluntary contributions from foundations, corporations and individuals” but does not disclose any details.5 Altria has made unspecified donations to the organisation since 2014.67891011

R Street Institute states that it works “extensively on both state and national policy”  in the US and that donations help it to pursue its “mission and work across the country”.2 However it has also lobbied for the lower regulation and taxation of newer nicotine and tobacco products in the US and in low and middle-income countries (LMICs).

Activities

“Integrated Harm Reduction”

One of the featured issues on R Street Institute’s website is harm reduction. It states that it “aims for integrated harm reduction with tobacco, opioid and sexual behavior” and that it believes “an ‘abstinence only’ approach to risky behaviours will not work on a population-wide basis”.12 As of April 2022, six out of the seven regulatory comments on harm reduction published on its website related to tobacco.13141516

The majority of regulatory comments on harm reduction published on its website relate to tobacco.17

Many of its publications and lobbying letters echo tobacco industry arguments, including the need to regulate newer products differently from other tobacco products, and criticising bans on product flavourings.12 Some articles have also been published on the Heartland Institute website.18

In 2022 R Street launched a “Safer From Harm Coalition” and website.1619 It stated that the aim was to “begin unifying previously siloed areas of harm reduction public policy under one banner.”16

R Street’s tax returns show that it sponsored the conference of the National Harm Reduction Coalition in Puerto Rico in 2022.20 It also paid the Influence Foundation US$14, 000 to produce 8 articles on harm reduction in Filter magazine.20

Lobbying in the US

  • Letter to the Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee’s Meeting in 2024, in support of the Modified Risk Tobacco Product (MRTP) application for General Snus, a Philip Morris International (PMI)/Swedish Match product.21
  • Report published in 2024, urging the FDA to “move quickly to approve a wide variety of products so that those who smoke combustible cigarettes have a multitude of options available to help them switch”.22
  • Letter to US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2023, commenting on the Center for Tobacco Products’ strategic plan23 Also hosted an “expert panel on Capitol Hill to discuss the new era of nicotine and tobacco control”.16
  • In 2022, R Street reported that its “targeted approaches to public policy education and outreach helped beat back anti-tobacco harm reduction bills in Hawai’i, Rhode Island, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota and Vermont that would not have been beneficial to harm reduction policies.”15
  • Letter to House Energy & Commerce Oversight & Investigations Subcommittee, February 2020, regarding the potential positive impact of e-cigarettes on public health.24
  • Letter to the FDA, September 2018, urging the Food and Drug Administration to grant British American Tobacco /Reynolds American a Modified-Risk Tobacco Product (MRTP) status for its Camel snus, arguing that this would benefit public health.25
  • Letter to the FDA , June 2018, regarding the potential lowering of nicotine levels in conventional cigarettes. Citing potential risks of illicit tobacco, the letter urged the FDA to avoid “excessive regulatory barriers” and “provide a risk-proportionate route to market for low-risk, non-combustible alternatives, such as e-cigarettes, heated tobacco [HTPs] and smokeless tobacco products.”26
  • Letter to the FDA, August 2017, supporting PMI’s Modified Risk Tobacco Product application for its heated tobacco product (HTP) IQOS.27
  • Lobbying letters have also been sent to US district and city councils.2829

Lobbying in LMICs

R Street Institute has published press releases, articles and consultation submissions,3031 in relation to tobacco control measures in LMICs:

Vietnam

A letter was sent to the Vietnamese Prime Minister in June 2020, calling for looser regulation on next generation products saying that: “these products present a public health opportunity to improve the lives of people who use combustible products and cannot or do not want to stop.”32 The letter also criticised the use of health warnings, standardized packaging and other evidence-based tobacco control measures in place in Vietnam.32

Thailand

A press release was published in November 2020, promoting a policy paper titled “Exploring the Differences in Tobacco Policy between the United Kingdom and Thailand” which recommended the use of e-cigarettes to reduce smoking rates.3334

In 2023 R Street published a report on its website titled the “Impact of Cultural Pressures on Tobacco Harm Reduction in South East Asia”.35

South Africa

Comments to a consultation on taxation of e-cigarettes were submitted in January 2022, arguing for lower taxes for “lower-risk products”. This also referred to PMI’s heated tobacco product IQOS and described HTPs inaccurately as “electronic nicotine delivery systems” (ENDS).36

Attended Concordia Summit

R Street Institute has attended the Concordia Summit, which up to September 2023 was supported by Philip Morris International.3738

Current and former policy and research staff

  • Jeffrey Smith, Resident Senior Fellow, Integrated Harm Reduction. Previously employed in science and regulatory affairs at Reynolds American Inc (owned by BAT since 2017).39
  • Pritika C. Kumar, former Resident Senior Fellow for Integrated Harm Reduction Policy. Previously a regulatory scientist at Altria.40
  • Brad Rodu, former Associate Fellow, focusing on “substituting safer tobacco products for smokers who are unable or unwilling to quit smoking with conventional cessation methods”. His research at the University of Louisville has been supported by tobacco industry funding.41
  • Joel Nitzkin, former Senior Fellow, consultant on harm reduction, worked on “shaping much of the R Street Institute tobacco control policy and speaking on behalf of such policy to state and local authorities, the American Medical Association and federal authorities”.42

A full list of current staff can be found on the R Street Institute website.

Relevant Links

Tobacco Tactics Resources

References

  1. R Street Institute, Who We Are, website, undated, accessed March 2022
  2. abR Street Institute, Support R Street, website, undated, accessed October 2024
  3. The Centre for Media and Democracy, R Street Institute, Source Watch, undated, accessed June 2022
  4. R Street Institute, profile, Propublica Nonprofit Explorer
  5. R Street Institute, RSI PPP Statement, website, May 2020, accessed April 2022
  6. J. Glenza, S. Kelly, J. Adolphe, Free-market groups and the tobacco industry – full database, The Guardian,  January 2019, accessed November 2020
  7. S. Kaplan, M. Richtel, Tobacco and E-cigarette lobbyists circle as F.D.A chief exist, New York Times, 15 March 2019, accessed April 2022
  8. Altria, 2019 Recipients of Charitable Contributions from the Altria Family of Companies, archived 20 March 2020, accessed April 2022
  9. Altria, 2020 Recipients of Charitable Contributions from the Altria Family of Companies, undated, accessed August 2022
  10. Altria, 2022 Recipients of Charitable Contributions from the Altria Family of Companies, archived July 2023, accessed October 2024
  11. Altria, 2023 Recipients of Charitable Contributions from the Altria Family of Companies, archived May 2023, accessed October 2024
  12. abR Street Institute, Harm Reduction, website, undated, accessed April 2022
  13. R Street Institute, Publications: Regulatory Comments, website, undated, accessed April 2022
  14. R Street Institute, Our Theory of Change for the Future of Harm Reduction, website blog, 25 April 2021, accessed October 2024
  15. abR Street Institute, Highlights Report 2022: Harm Reduction, pg 11, available from rstreet.org
  16. abcdR Street Institute, Highlights Report 2023: Integrated Harm Reduction, pg 17, available from rstreet.org
  17. R Street Institute, Publications: Regulatory Comments, website, undated, accessed October 2024
  18. R Street Institute, The Role of Flavouring in Tobacco Harm Reduction, available from heartland Institute Website, December 2015, accessed June 2022
  19. R Street Institute, Saferfromharm.org, website, undated archived December 2022, accessed October 2024
  20. abR Street Institute, Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax 2022, tax return. Available from propublica.org
  21. R Street Institute, R Street Comments on the Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee’s Meeting on the General Snus MRTP Renewal Application, website, 18 June 2024, accessed October 2024
  22. J. Smith/ R-Street Institute, Flavour Can Save Lives: The Neurobiological Rationale for Flavor in Reduced-Risk Nicotine Products, 8 February 2024, accessed February 2024
  23. R Street Institute, R Street Comments on the FDA-CTP Strategic Plan, website, 24 August 2023, accessed October 2023
  24. R Street Institute, Letter to House Energy & Commerce Oversight & Investigations Subcommittee regarding e-cigarette manufacturers’ impact on public health, February 2020, accessed November 2020
  25. R Street Institute, Modified Risk Tobacco Product Applications: Applications for Six Camel Snus Smokeless Tobacco Products Submitted by R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, 18 September 2018, accessed November 2020
  26. R Street Institute, Docket No. FDA-2017-N-6189 (83 Fed. Reg. 11,818, March 16, 2018) Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Tobacco Product Standard for Nicotine in Level of Certain Tobacco Products, 29 June 2018, accessed March 2022
  27. R Street Institute Comment on IQOS Modified Risk Tobacco Application, available from Heartland Institute website, 23 August 2017, archived 25 April 2019, accessed April 2022
  28. R Street Institute, Letter to Louisville Metro Department of Public Health and Wellness, October 2016, accessed November 2020
  29. S. Greenhut, Letter to Missoula City Council On Flavoured Tobacco Ban, R Street Institute website, 30 October 2020, accessed April 2022
  30. R Street Institute, Harm Reduction Publications, undated, accessed November 2020
  31. R Street Institute, Tobacco Harm Reduction Archive, website, accessed October 2024
  32. abR Street Institute, In Support of Risk-Proportionate Regulation of E-cigarettes and Heated Tobacco Products, June 2020, accessed November 2020
  33. R Street Institute, Thailand Should Follow the United Kingdom’s Lead: Examining Tobacco Policy Abroad, October 2020, accessed November 2020
  34. A. Ulasevich, C. Boyd, Exploring the Differences in Tobacco Policy between the United Kingdom and Thailand, 5 October 2020, accessed April 2021
  35. J. Smith/R Street Institute, Impact of Cultural Pressures on Tobacco Harm Reduction in South East Asia, website, 2 November 2023, accessed October 2024
  36. C. Boyd, Encouraging Risk-Proportionate Tobacco Regulation in South Africa, website, 25 January 2022, accessed March 2022
  37. R Street Institute, Important and innovative proposals to reduce the risk of smoking in the world, June 2018, accessed November 2020
  38. Concordia, Members, website, undated, accessed September 2021
  39. R Street Institute, Jeffrey Smith profile, website, undated, archived April 2023, accessed October 2024
  40. R Street Institute, Pritika C. Kumar profile, website, undated, archived October 2021, accessed March 2022
  41. R Street Institute, Brad Rodu profile, website, undated, accessed July 2021
  42. R Street Institute, Joel Nitzkin profile, undated, archived August 2024, accessed October 2024