Delon Human

This page was last edited on at

Delon Human is a South African doctor who has a history of collaborating with British American Tobacco (BAT) on its “harm reduction” activities.12345

Dr. Human set up the company NicoLIFE (see below), which provided consultancy services to BAT.

He is the founder of Health Diplomats, a consulting company that has “partnered” with BAT, via the tobacco corporation’s subsidiary Nicoventures.345 Health Diplomats supports harm reduction groups in Africa, Asia and Latin America; has lobbied for less stringent regulation of newer nicotine and tobacco products in Australia; and established a ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ campaign which “encourages other countries to follow the Swedish model”.6

Human has stated that he has received expenses for attending the Global Tobacco and Nicotine Forum, which is sponsored by the tobacco industry.57

In March 2023 Human stated that he “[c]urrently [had] no contract with any nicotine company whatsoever”.57

  • Read about how the tobacco industry uses the concept of harm reduction to further its business goals.

Background

Dr. Human served as Secretary General of the World Medical Association (WMA) from 1998 to 2004.89

Human is often referred to as having served as an “adviser to the World Health Organization (WHO) Director-General and UN Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon”.1011 Although he was briefly considered an advisor to the WHO Commission on Ending Childhood Obesity (ECHO) during his time as Secretary-General of the International Food and Beverage Alliance (see below), he was removed by the WHO after his links to the tobacco industry became known.12

Relationship with the Tobacco Industry

NicoLIFE

Human set up NicoLIFE in 2008 to promote a “…wise nicotine policy, science and products to enable smoking cessation and reduce tobacco harm”.13

In 2010 BAT funded NicoLIFE/Human to write a book on harm reduction, titled “Wise Nicotine”.2 The foreword stated that BAT’s role was limited to funding and “supplying information on request and to reviewing extracts from the final version of the book for technical accuracy”.2

BAT’s 2013 Sustainability Report stated that “NicoLife has provided consultancy services to BAT on our approach to harm reduction”.1

Human was quoted in the report, saying that:

through its public commitment to tobacco harm reduction…[BAT] makes itself accountable to its consumers and society. This should be applauded and, if successful, BAT could become part of the solution to addressing the epidemic of tobacco-related disease.1

NicoLIFE is no longer active.14

Health Diplomats

Human is the President and CEO of Health Diplomats, a health and consulting company he set up in 2007.15 Between March 2019 and March 2023, the Health Diplomats website made clear its relationship to BAT:16

Our current work, in advancing tobacco harm reduction policies, science and products, is in partnership with Nicoventures, a subsidiary of the British American Tobacco company. The goal is to help establish tobacco harm reduction policies and science. In addition, to increase smokers’ access to innovative, non-combustible forms of nicotine delivery, thereby improving smoking cessation and global health”.34516

In February 2019, Riccardo Polosa, a harm reduction researcher who had previously accepted funding from Philip Morris International (PMI), wrote to the UK Parliament and informed them that he was contracted by Health Diplomats to provide consultancy services to “subsidiaries of British American Tobacco…”.17

In May 2023, there was no content available on the Health Diplomats website.18 The site was updated in 2024, now stating that Health Diplomats has “extensive and direct experience in developing effective strategies for government relations and corporate affairs in the pharmaceutical, food & beverage, alcohol, tobacco, nicotine and medical device industries”.19 A disclosure page stated:

“In the tobacco and nicotine space, harm reduction services have been provided to tobacco manufacturers (multiple companies within the GTNF list of sponsors) and nicotine product manufacturers (pharmaceutical and consumer-based companies). Services have focused on cigarette smoking cessation, substitution and harm reduction in general.”20

GTNF is the industry-funded Global Tobacco Nicotine Forum. The list of sponsors can be found on its website.21 Human has spoken at GTNF events, for which he has been paid expenses.5222324252627

Health Diplomats’ Chief Operating Officer as of 2024, Jessica Perkins,15 previously worked at BAT/Nicoventures for 9 years, and has worked with other platforms linked to Health Diplomats (see below).28

The Health Diplomats website homepage feature an image of a United Nations (UN) building, and the statement “We fully subscribe to the UN’s call for multi-stakeholder engagement and multi-sector action to prevent and control noncommunicable diseases”.29 However Article 5.3 of the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC) obliges parties to protect health policy from interference by the tobacco industry and others representing its interests, and interaction should be limited to only that which is necessary for regulating the industry.30 (See also the TobaccoTactics long read on how the tobacco industry has appropriated the UN Sustainable Development Goals in order to promote its newer products, and claim a position as a legitimate stakeholder in matters of global development.)

Organisations and campaigns connected to Human

EuroSwiss Health

Human and Pierre-Yves Mayor established EuroSwiss Health SA in 2003. 31 32 This consultancy funded the 2014 Nutt et al study which assessed the relative harm of nicotine-containing products and, controversially, concluded that e-cigarette use is around 95% safer than smoking.33343536 Co-authors included Riccardo Polosa,36 and Karl Fagerstrom. Apart from funding this paper, EuroSwiss Health appears not to have conducted any other activities in tobacco harm reduction, or any other activity.

‘Smoke Free Sweden’

In March 2023, Health Diplomats launched a ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ campaign,3738 which “encourages other countries to follow the Swedish model when it comes to Tobacco Harm Reduction”.6 There is no funding information on the website, but ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ is described as a “non-profit” on its LinkedIn profile.39

The ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ website states that Sweden’s low smoking rates “can be attributed to Sweden’s pragmatic, risk-based approach in the regulation of alternative nicotine products”.38 It also states that the WHO FCTC should take a similar approach and ensure that “alternative nicotine products are acceptable, accessible, and affordable”.38 Among the products that the campaign advocates use of in this context are e-cigarettes, heated tobacco products and snus.40

Similar claims have been made previously by tobacco companies, which have referred to the ‘Swedish experience’ as proof of concept that switching smokers to snus can be an effective harm reduction approach. However, this theory has been challenged by public health experts. See The Swedish Experience for background, and below for an example of how this argument has been used to lobby against regulation in South Africa.

Outputs featured on the Swedish campaign website include a report commissioned by Health Diplomats, co-authored by Human, titled: ‘The Swedish Experience: A roadmap for a smoke-free society’.40 The report highlights several steps that the authors state are “key to driving considerable reductions in smoking prevalence”. This includes recommendations to reduce the regulation of newer nicotine and tobacco products, including: implementing “low or no excise tax on smoke free alternatives”, and “ensuring a range of flavours and nicotine concentrations for consumers to buy” so that, according to the authors, products are able to satisfy smokers.40 One of the other co-authors, Professor Karl Fagerström, has received consulting fees from Swedish Match and other tobacco companies (see below).414243 The third co-author, Dr Anders Milton, is listed as chair of the Snus Commission. This organisation is described as an “independent commission” but is funded by the Swedish Association of Snus Manufacturers,44 of which Swedish Match and BAT Sweden are members.45 Milton is also a member of the Oral Nicotine Commission (see below) and is involved in the Quit Like Sweden campaign established in April 2024.4647

Smoke-Free Sweden activities:

  • In April 2023, the authors submitted the report and related policy recommendations to the public consultation of the European Union Tobacco Products Directive (TPD), which aimed to evaluate the current legislative framework for tobacco control.4849
  • In September 2023, BAT featured a ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ video in a presentation to its investors.5051
  • In November 2023, following the postponement of the tenth session of the Conference of the Parties (COP10) to the WHO FCTC, ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ published a press release, urging the FCTC to use the delay “to consider smoke-free success stories like that of Sweden.”52
  • In 2025, Smoke Free Sweden put out a press release urging support for EU countries opposing Spain’s proposed ban on nicotine pouches.53

The ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ campaign has been cited by other organisations linked to Health Diplomats, including the African Harm Reduction Alliance (AHRA, see below), to lobby against a tobacco control bill in South Africa, as well as the Asia Harm Reduction Alliance (AsHRA, see below) to call for the use of harm reduction policies and products in Bangladesh.

 

The following organisations state on their websites that they are “supported by individual donors and Health Diplomats”, and that Health Diplomats also maintains the websites.545556

Africa Harm Reduction Alliance (AHRA)

In June 2015, Human and Kgosi Letlape co-founded the Africa Harm Reduction Alliance (AHRA).57 Letlape is the South Africa Commissioner for the ‘International Commission to Reignite the Fight Against Smoking’, which was funded by the PMI-financed Foundation for a Smoke-Free World (FSFW) in 2021.585960 Letlape is also President of the Africa Medical Association (Human is Secretary General).6162 Human and Letlape are the only personnel listed on the AHRA website.63

Challenged the inclusion of e-cigarettes in South Africa tobacco control bill

In his role as AHRA’s co-founder, Human has challenged the inclusion of e-cigarettes in the proposed South African Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Control Bill that was going through Parliament in 2019.6465 Human argued that by including e-cigarettes, the Bill treats such products as having the same risk profile as conventional cigarettes, whereas in Human’s view “new research show[s]…that vaping products are 95% to 99% safer than conventional cigarettes”.65 Here, Human may have been referring to findings of the evidence review published in March 2018 by Public Health England,66 whose stance on e-cigarettes has caused significant controversy both in Britain and internationally.67

An update to the bill was presented to Parliament in May 2023, and in his role as AHRA’s Secretary-General, Human called on the South African parliament to adopt the “Swedish way”. Citing Health Diplomat’s ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ campaign, Human stated that the bill could jeopardise hopes of South Africa becoming smoke-free.6869

AHRA published articles on its website opposing the bill, and held a tobacco harm reduction webinar, again citing the ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ campaign and Health Diplomats report.707172

The South African National Council Against Smoking criticised this lobbying, pointing out that it ignores Sweden’s “long history of strong tobacco control measures” with regulations on cigarettes also applicable to e-cigarettes.73

AHRA activities in Australia

Between November 2022 and January 2023, the Australian drug regulator, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), opened a consultation to consider proposed reform or regulations relating to e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products.74

Human co-authored a submission to the consultation in January in his role as Secretary General of AHRA, alongside Kgosi Letlape, co-founder of AHRA.75 The submission urged the regulator to adopt a tobacco harm reduction approach rather than impose further restrictions on its existing nicotine prescription model, such as bans on flavours and disposable e-cigarettes, nicotine level caps and restrictive plain packaging.75

The submission’s conflicts of interest (COI) statement failed to mention Human’s relationship with BAT, despite a requirement for submitters to disclose any past or current ‘actual or perceived’ tobacco or e-cigarette industry links. Instead, Human wrote that AHRA had “not received any tobacco industry funding” and he had “currently, no contract with any nicotine company whatsoever”.75 Human subsequently updated his COI in a separate response form at the TGA’s request following a media article exposing how some submitters had failed to disclose their industry links. The statement included slightly more detail on how he had advised pharmaceutical companies (Pfizer, Johnson & Johnson) “on optimising NRT as part of smoking cessation and companies developing oral nicotine pouches & ENDS” but did not mention Health Diplomat’s partnership with BAT/Nicoventures.77 The co-authors did not submit COI declarations.

In March 2022, AHRA made a submission to Australia’s Department of Health public consultation on the proposed National Tobacco Strategy 2022-30.76 stating that: “…the Government of Australia, should decide strategically to exploit the opportunities of tobacco harm reduction and move to a system of risk-proportionate regulation covering all consumer nicotine products”. 76

Criticised COP 10

At COP 10, Letlape stated that proposals by the WHO would “criminalise tobacco harm reduction activism” and that the WHO FCTC was trying shut down debate and freedom of the press.77

Asia Harm Reduction Alliance (AsHRA)

AsHRA was established in September 2022,78 with its launch announced by AHRA and tobaccoharmreduction.net (below).7879

The AsHRA website does not appear to list members or personnel.80 According to her LinkedIn profile, Jessica Perkins has been AsHRA’s Chief Operating Officer since January 2023.28

AsHRA’s stated mission is to “reduce drug, alcohol and tobacco-related death and disease in Asia Pacific and the Middle East by educating policymakers on the benefits of harm reduction policies.”81

On 27 May 2023, AsHRA organised the THR Summit 2023 event in Dhaka, Bangladesh, alongside Voice of Vapers Bangladesh. AsHRA stated that it aimed to “raise awareness of the benefits of tobacco harm reduction for individual and population health, the economy, and establish Bangladesh as a best practice and proof of concept”. Speakers listed included Human, Kgosi Letlape and Derek Yach (former President of FSFW).82 Human again promoted the Swedish model, which he said was “being followed in countries like the United Kingdom, which now offers free e-cigarettes to those who want to quit smoking.”8384  The Dhaka Tribune reported that on the same day, it hosted a round table event in association with AsHRA titled “The role of Tobacco Harm Reduction in achieving Hon’ble Prime Minister’s Smoke-free Bangladesh vision by 2040”. Human again argued that tobacco harm reduction should be made part of Bangladesh’s strategy.85

Pan American Harm Reduction Alliance (PAHRA)

PAHRA was launched in April 2023, with Human referred to as “chief executive” in a media report.86 The PAHRA website does not appear to list its members or personnel.87

In May 2023, it held an event in São Paulo titled the ‘South American THR Seminar’, which was moderated by Human, alongside Jessica Perkins. Other speaker listed included Kgosi Letlape, Derek Yach and Anders Milton.8886

Tobaccoharmreduction.net

Human is the Founder of THR.net,89 The website does not list members or personnel, other than Human. However, according to the Health Diplomats website, this platform is led by Jessica Perkins.15

The THR website states that it “provides comprehensive, science-based information on tobacco harm reduction…[and] advocacy tools and guidelines for those who want to promote the development and establishment of harm reduction policies, science, regulated products and consumer empowerment.”9089

The site also advocates for the World Health Organization and governments worldwide to distinguish between smoked and smoke-free products, stating that nicotine products should be regulated in a risk-based, proportionate manner.91

In March 2022, a post on the THR.net website encouraged users of e-cigarettes to make submissions to Australia’s Department of Health public consultation on the proposed National Tobacco Strategy 2022-30.92

Oral Nicotine Commission

Human is chairman of the Oral Nicotine Commission. The commission describes itself as “an independent body made up of leading figures in the international medical, scientific and public health policy communities, whose goal is to help build the evidence base and raise awareness of the benefits of oral nicotine among governments, public health leaders and the public, thus countering negative, unfounded preconceptions and stereotypes.”93

There is no funding information on the website. The contact e-mail address for the organisation is tobaccoharmreduction.net.94 Members of the commission wrote a report on oral nicotine, “supported by Health Diplomats”, which was published in 2020.95

The commission held a meeting “in cooperation” with tobaccoharmreduction.net and AHRA in 2022, to discuss Sweden’s low smoking rate and “the worldwide issues with the regulation and acceptance of snus and oral nicotine products”.96

Other members of the commission include:97

  • Dr Kgosi Letlape, co-founder of AHRA and President of the Africa Medical Association.
  • Dr Anders Milton, owner and CEO of Milton Consulting, chair of the Snus Commission, co-author of the ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ report.40 involved in the ‘Quit Like Sweden’ campaign.4647
  • Dr Karl Fagerström, founding member of the Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco (SRNT), and co-author of the ‘Smoke Free Sweden’ report.40 He has received consulting fees from Swedish Match and other tobacco companies, including BAT and PMI.424143 See The International Association on Smoking Control and Harm Reduction (SCOHRE) for more details.

Other Activities

Report focussed on harm reduction in LMICs

Human was listed as an author of a report published in October 2023, titled ‘Integrating harm reduction into tobacco control. How many lives could be saved by accelerating tobacco control policies in low and middle-income countries, specifically Kazakhstan, Pakistan, South Africa, and Bangladesh?’98

Derek Yach, former President of FSFW, was the principal author of the report.99 Evidence cited in the report includes tobacco company research, and resources funded by FSFW.

The report summary ends with a call for action at COP10:

“This report demands several actions. Member States at COP10 need to activate the harm reduction provisions of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC)… Governments need to regulate nicotine products proportionate to the risk they pose to health…THR users need to galvanise into a powerful movement that advocates pro-THR policies. Industry needs to step up THR activities in LMICS and consider developing products that meet medical licensing approval”.

THR.net held the launch event for a report.99

CORESTA

CORESTA is an industry association founded in 1956 ‘for scientific research relative to tobacco’. In 2016, Human was a keynote speaker at the CORESTA Congress in Berlin.100 He was invited to speak about harm reduction, the “opportunities for Next Generation Products” and “bridging the gap between industry science and public health”.100101

Global Forum on Nicotine (GFN)

Human has also appeared on the list of speakers at the Global Forum on Nicotine, an event which has provided a platform for the tobacco industry and others to promote tobacco harm reduction.102

Other Affiliations

  • According to its website, Human is a member of Concordia.103 He was listed as a speaker at the 2018 Concordia Americas Summit.104 For more information on this global organisation and its relationship with PMI, see Concordia.
  • In August 2019, Human was appointed to the Board of Directors of First Columbia Development Corp, a company specialising in medicinal cannabis.105
  • In November 2016, Human joined the Medical Advisory Board of Canadian cannabis company, PharmaCielo.106 In November 2019 he was listed as Chair of the advisory board.107 Subsequently, members of this advisory board were not listed on the PharmaCeilo website.108 For more information see Cannabis.
  • From 2010 to 2014, Human was the Secretary-General of lobby group International Food and Beverage Alliance (IFBA),5789 an alliance of multinational food and drink companies.109 Human was allegedly removed as IFBA’s Secretary-General after his tobacco industry links became known to the WHO.12
  • The Human Salmon Foundation, a charitable organisation set up in 2007 by Human and his wife, to “enabl[e]…vulnerable children to face the future with confidence by supporting sustainable health, education and community programs”.110

Relevant Links

Health Diplomats website

TobaccoTactics Resources

British American Tobacco

Newer Nicotine and Tobacco Products: British American Tobacco

E-cigarettes: British American Tobacco

Global Tobacco and Nicotine Forum

Country Profile: South Africa

TCRG Research

The Science for Profit Model—How and why corporations influence science and the use of science in policy and practice, T. Legg, J. Hatchard and A.B. Gilmore, Plos One, 2021, 16(6):e025327

References

  1. abcBritish American Tobacco, Why it Matters – A Focus on Harm Reduction, BAT’s Sustainability Focus Report, 2013, available from bat.com
  2. abcD. Human, ”Wise Nicotine. Uncovering tobacco harm reduction, the best kept secret in public health”, Dennis Barber Limited, 26 November 2010
  3. abcHealth Diplomats, Welcome to Health Diplomats, website, undated, archived 29 March 2023, accessed July 2023
  4. abcM. Davey, Pro-tobacco lobbyists circle Australian government’s proposed vaping reforms, The Guardian, 20 March 2023, accessed November 2023
  5. abcdefM. Davey, Tobacco-linked organisations and executives fail to declare interests to TGA vaping inquiry, The Guardian, 24 March 2023, accessed November 2023
  6. abSmoke Free Sweden, Sweden’s smoke-free success defies WHO statements on e-cigarettes, say experts, website, June 2023, accessed June 2023
  7. abcdTherapeutic Goods Administration, Proposed reforms to the regulation of nicotine vaping products: Response 812009592, Delon Human, 10 January 2023, accessed July 2023
  8. World Medical Association, New Secretary General takes over at World Medical Association, WMA website, 19 February 1998, accessed November 2019
  9. World Medical Association, New WMA Secretary General Appointed, WMA website, 11 October 2004, accessed November 2019
  10. Speakers: Dr. Delon Human, CannaTech 2019 website, 24-26 November 2019, accessed November 2019
  11. PharmaCielo, Dr. Delon Human profile, 2019, accessed November 2019
  12. abWorld Health Organization, Email reply to TobaccoTactics editor 19 November 2019  11:43, subject: RE: Question about Delon Human’s connection with WHO
  13. D. Human, Statement by Dr. Delon Human at the FDA Public Workshop on the Risks and Benefits of Long‐term use of Nicotine Replacement Therapies Washington DC, 27 October 2010, archived 24 October 2016
  14. NicoLIFE, easymonitoring,ch, accessed November 2019
  15. abcHealth Diplomats, The Team, website, undated, accessed March 2024
  16. abHealth Diplomats, President and CEO, undated,  archived 21 March 2019, accessed November 2019
  17. R. Polosa, Letter submitted by Professor Riccardo Polosa (ECG0106), February 2019, accessed March 2019
  18. Health Diplomats, website, undated, archived 28 May 2023, accessed July 2023
  19. Health Diplomats, Services, website, undated, accessed March 2024
  20. Health Diplomats, Disclosure, website, undated, accessed March 2024
  21. GTNF, GTNF Sponsors, website, undated, archived February 2024, accessed March 2024
  22. Global Tobacco Networking Forum, Conference Website 2012, accessed December 2013
  23. Global Tobacco Networking Forum, Global Tobacco Networking Forum 2013, accessed September 2013
  24. Global Tobacco and Nicotine Forum, Look who’s talking, 2015, accessed December 2017
  25. Global Tobacco and Nicotine Forum, 2021 Speakers: Fresh voices and viewpoints, GTNF website, archived August 2021, accessed May 2023
  26. Global Tobacco and Nicotine Forum, Seoul 2023 Speakers, GTNF website, archived September 2023, accessed September 2023
  27. GTNF, IN FOCUS:THR, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  28. abJessica Perkins, LinkedIn profile, undated, accessed July 2023
  29. Health Diplomats, Homepage, website, undated, accessed March 2024
  30. World Health Organization, WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, 2003, available from fctc.who.int
  31. Moneyhouse, EuroSwiss Health SA entry, last change 15 April 2019, accessed November 2019
  32. EuroSwiss Health SA: 713783, Open Corporates entry, undated, accessed July 2023
  33. D. Nutt, L.D. Phillips, D. Balfour, H.V. Curran, M. Dockrell, J. Foulds, K. Fagerstrom, K. Letlape, A. Milton, R. Polosa, J. Ramsey, D. Sweanor, Estimating the Harms of Nicotine-Containing Products Using the MCDA Approach, European Addiction Research 20 (5) September 2014, accessed November 2019
  34. Public Health England, Underpinning evidence for the estimate that e-cigarette use is around 95% safer than smoking: Authors’ note, 2015, accessed November 2019
  35. S. Boseley, Public Health England under fire for saying e-cigarettes are 95% safer, The Guardian, 28 August 2015, accessed November 2019
  36. abE-cigarettes: Public Health England’s evidence-based confusion, The Lancet, Editorial, 29 August 2015, 386(9996): p829, doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)00042-2
  37. Smoke Free Sweden, website homepage, undated, accessed June 2023
  38. abcSmoke Free Sweden, About Us, website, archived March 2023, accessed June 2023
  39. Smoke Free Sweden, LinkedIn profile, undated, accessed November 2023
  40. abcdeSmoke Free Sweden/D. Human, A. Milton, K. Fagerström, The Swedish Experience: A roadmap for a smoke-free society, March 2023, accessed June 2023
  41. abPatwardhan, K. Fagerström, The New Nicotine Pouch Category: A Tobacco Harm Reduction Tool?, Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 2021, 24(4), doi:10.1093/ntr/ntab198
  42. abK. Fagerström, Can alternative nicotine products put the final nail in the smoking coffin?, Harm Reduction Journal, 2022, 131(19). doi:10.1186/s12954-022-00722-5
  43. abJ.R. Hughes, K.O. Fagerstrom, J.E. Henningfield, B. Rodu, J.E. Rose, S. Shiffman, Why we work with the tobacco industry, letter to the Editor, Addiction, 15 October 2018, 114: 374–375. https://doi.org/10.1111/add.14461[/ref] (PMI had acquired over 90% of Swedish Match in late November 2022, and the whole company by February 2023).111Swedish Match, Company History, website, undated, accessed March 2023
  44. Snus Kommissionen/Snus  Commission, Om oss/About us, website, undated, archived June 2023, accessed August 2023
  45. Svenska Snustillverkarföreningen/Swedish Association of Snus Manufacturers, Om oss/About us, website, undated, accessed July 2024
  46. abQuit Like Sweden, Let’s Quit Like Sweden, website, undated, archived June 2024, accessed November 2024
  47. abQuit Like Sweden, , website, accessed November 2024
  48. Smoke Free Sweden, Press Release – EU TPD Consultation: Will the EU follow the Swedish model?, website, 25 April 2023, accessed June 2023
  49. European Commission, Evaluation of the legislative framework for tobacco control, consultation, 2023, accessed June 2023
  50. British American Tobacco, 2023 Barclays Consumer Staples Conference: Presentation, slide 31, 5 September 2023, available from bat.com
  51. British American Tobacco, 2023 Barclays Consumer Staples Conference: Transcript, 5 September 2023, available from bat.com
  52. Smoke Free Sweden, Experts recommend seizing the COP 10 delay as a catalyst for tobacco control innovation, 21 November 2023, website , archived January 2024, accessed January 2024
  53. Smoke Free Sweden,EU nations push back against Spain’s ‘dangerous’ nicotine pouch ban, press release, 19 May 2025. Supplied to Tobacco Tactics
  54. AHRA, Privacy Policy, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  55. PAHRA, Privacy Policy, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  56. Tobaccoharmreduction.net, Privacy Policy, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  57. abD. Human, LinkedIn profile, undated, accessed November 2019
  58. The International Commission to Reignite the Fight Against Smoking, Dr Kgosi Letlape, Commissioner, South Africa, website, undated, archived October 2021, accessed September 2023
  59. The International Commission to Reignite the Fight Against Smoking, Commission Report: Reignite the Fight Against Smoking, September 2021, archived September 2021, accessed September 2023
  60. Foundation for a Smoke-Free World, Form 990-PF, 2021 Tax Return, 16 May 2022, accessed May 2022
  61. Africa Medical Association, About AfMA, website, undated, accessed June 2024 2023
  62. Africa needs tobacco harm reduction sensitisation, MBC Online, 16 December 2022, accessed September 2023
  63. Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, About, website, undated, accessed June 2024
  64. International Bar Association, Vaping industry slams new tobacco bill, Legal Brief Africa, 11 November 2019, accessed November 2019
  65. abhealth-E, Vaping industry slams ‘moralistic’ new tobacco bill, iol.co.za, 10 July 2018, accessed November 2019
  66. Public Health England, Evidence review of e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products 2018: executive summary, updated 2 March 2018, accessed November 2019
  67. A. Matthews-King, Harmful effects of vaping being ignored by UK health authorities, leading professor says, The Independent, 23 April 2019, accessed November 2019
  68. Smoke Free Sweden, Get South Africa quitting like Sweden to save smokers’ lives, experts urge Ramaphosa, website, 5 May 2023, accessed June 2023
  69. S. Rall, Experts call on Ramaphosa to adopt Sweden’s anti-smoking pass at Presidential Health Summit, IOL, 5 May 2023, accessed June 2023
  70. Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, Quit Like Sweden To Save Millions Of Smokers’ Lives, Experts Urge SA Lawmakers Johannesburg 1 May 2023, website, undated, archived June 2023, accessed June 2023
  71. Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, Outdated, Short-sighted and Unscientific Tobacco Bill Will Cost Lives, Say Experts, website, undated, archived June 2023, accessed June 2023
  72. Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, Can Tobacco Harm Reduction Save Lives in Africa? April 2023, accessed August 2023
  73. Nyatsanza. S, Misleading tobacco industry stealth advertising misrepresents Swedish e-cigarette model, Daily Maverick, 21 May 2023, accessed June 2023
  74. Therapeutic Goods Administration, Consultation: Proposed reforms to the regulation of nicotine vaping products, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  75. abcTherapeutic Goods Administration, Proposed reforms to the regulation of nicotine vaping products: Response 786907285, Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, 10 January 2023, accessed July 2023
  76. abAustralian Government, Department of Health and Aged Care, National Tobacco Strategy 2022-2030: Response 1013011463, Africa Harm Reduction Alliance, 22 March 2022, accessed July 2023
  77. World Health Organisation to Censor Media on Tobacco Harm Reduction, South Africa Today, 8 February 2024, accessed February 2024
  78. abTobaccoharmreduction.net, New Platform Revealed: The Asia Harm Reduction Alliance, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  79. AHRA, New Asia Harm Reduction Alliance Platform Revealed, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  80. Asian Harm Reduction Alliance, About, website, undated, accessed June 2024
  81. AsHRA, About, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  82. AsHRA, Can Tobacco Harm Reduction Save Lives in Bangladesh and Asia?, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  83. AsHRA, International health experts: Bangladesh can be smoke-free by 2040 if it adopts the Swedish model, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  84. Tobacco harm reduction framework necessary to achieve PM’s smoke-free vision by 2040, The Daily Star, 4 June 2023, accessed June 2023
  85. Leading global experts shed light on how Bangladesh can be a regional leader in tobacco harm reduction, Dhaka Tribune, 30 May 2023, accessed July 2023
  86. abS.P. Pinto, Experts advocate tobacco harm reduction alternatives [translation], Ponder 360, 12 May 2023, accessed July 2023
  87. Pan American Harm Reduction Alliance, About, website, undated, accessed June 2024
  88. PAHRA, Can Tobacco Harm Reduction Save Lives in South America, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  89. abcTobaccoharmreduction.net, Meet Dr Delon Human, website, undated, archived May 2023, accessed June 2023
  90. Tobaccoharmreduction.net, About, website, undated, archived May 2023, accessed June 2023
  91. Tobaccoharmreduction.net, Benefits, website, undated, archived May 2023, accessed June 2023
  92. TobaccoHarmReduction.net, The Australian Department of Health is seeking feedback on how to reduce smoking in the draft National Tobacco Strategy 2022-2030, website, undated, accessed April 2023
  93. Oral Nicotine Commission, Our Mission, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  94. Oral Nicotine Commission, Privacy Policy, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  95. Oral Nicotine Commission 2020 Report:  Prevent Disease, Save Lives, 2020, accessed August 2023
  96. tobaccoharmreduction.net, Oral health experts highlight Swedish success with snus products, website, undated, accessed July 2023
  97. Oral Nicotine Commission, About Us, website, undated, accessed June 2023
  98. Smoke Free Sweden, Integrating harm reduction into tobacco control. How many lives could be saved by accelerating tobacco control policies in Kazakhstan, Pakistan, South Africa, and Bangladesh?, October 2023, accessed November 2023
  99. abTHR.net, More than 2.5 million lives could be saved in four LMICs countries by adopting Sweden’s smoke-free strategy – major new report, website, 25 October 2023, accessed November 2023
  100. abCoresta, Newsletter Issue 46, website, December 2016, accessed November 2019
  101. Coresta, Newsletter Issue 45, website, August 2016, accessed November 2019
  102. Global Forum on Nicotine, Speakers 2014, website, undated, accessed February 2018
  103. Concordia, Community: Dr. Delon Human, website, undated, accessed September 2023
  104. Concordia, 2018 Concordia Americas Summit Speakers, website, undated, accessed September 2023
  105. First Columbia Development Corp. Appoints Recognized Global Health Leader Dr. Delon Human to Board of Directors, Bloomberg News, 14 August 2019, accessed August 2023
  106. PharmaCielo, PharmaCielo Appoints New and Extended Medical and Scientific Advisory Board, press release, 30 November 2016, accessed October 2020
  107. PharmaCielo, Medical and Scientific Advisory Board, website, undated, archived November 2019, accessed June 2024p
  108. PharmCielo, Strength in Leadership, website, undated, archived 24 May 2020, accessed September 2023
  109. International Food and Beverage Alliance, IFBA website, archived October 2014, accessed November 2019
  110. The Human Salmon Foundation, Our story, website, 2019, accessed November 2019